Splicetoday

Moving Pictures
Nov 18, 2026, 06:26AM

Mountains and Mysteries

Limits of knowledge in the Himalayas and beyond.

1469.jpg?ixlib=rails 2.1

Tenzing’s an excellent film about Tenzing Norgay, who summited Everest with Edmund Hillary. I was fascinated by a 1920s scene in which young Tenzing meets George Mallory, who died on Everest. This is a bit of dramatic license, including Tenzing trying on the affable Mallory’s boots, though the possibility their paths crossed was raised by a 2000 book Snow in the Kingdom. Tenzing was ethnically Tibetan, not a Sherpa (an ethnic group as well as a profession), something the film highlights that was long obscured by competing nationalist priorities among Nepal, India and China as to his origin (and hence childhood locations).

The 1953 moment at the top of the world also has dramatic license, as the film shows Tenzing and Hillary getting to the summit together, after each politely says, “After you.” Official history says Hillary stepped there first while Tenzing held a rope for him; they were exhausted and wearing oxygen masks, which likely impeded conversation, as did Tenzing’s English, which was more limited than in the film, where he’s become fluent at this point. A scene of Hillary’s near-fatal fall into a crevasse is depicted faithfully, however, and was filmed with actors Tom Hiddleston (Hillary) and Genden Phuntsok (Tenzing) on a glacier in New Zealand.

Despite their status as prime examples of objective physical reality, mountains are shrouded in various unknowns and debatable points. Mallory’s body was found on Everest in 1999, and partial remains of his climbing partner, Andrew Irvine, were discovered in 2024. There’s no evidence they made it to the summit, but it can’t be ruled out either. Incidentally Hillary Clinton’s claim that she was named after Sir Edmund Hillary wasn’t true but might have been a “sweet family story” her mother told the girl to inspire her.

A day after my wife and I saw the film with a trial subscription to Apple TV, I moderated a New Jersey history bowl competition for middle schoolers. One team was four kids from a public school, the other just one homeschooled student. I read a question where the answer was supposed to be “the Alps” and the homeschooled kid buzzed in with “the Alpine mountains.” After I’d ruled him wrong, and given the correct answer, he said he wanted to file a protest, on grounds “the Alpine Mountains” is the range’s official name. The other team then weighed in, sportsmanlike, that their opponent was correct.

I awarded the homeschooled kid the points, and later was irritated at finding “the Alpine Mountains” isn’t the official name of anything. I’d been bamboozled by bullshit.

Or had I? Further reading indicated that while “alpine” is often a generic, lower-case adjective, referring broadly to mountains or skiing, “Alpine” would indicate the European Alps, whereas, for example, New Zealand’s Southern Alps would be “Southern Alpine.” Arguably, I should’ve awarded the points as the kid had the correct range in mind. Some questions have instructions on what variations to accept or, alternatively, “prompt” for a more-precise answer, but sometimes ambiguities require a moderator’s judgment.

I’ve traveled to Nepal twice, as I’ve previously written, and each time spent part of the trip at the excellent Tiger Mountain Pokhara Lodge, of which Hillary was present for the founding in 1998. There one gets striking views of the Annapurna range of the Himalayas, including Machapuchare, also known as Fishtail Mountain. Officially, no one’s ever climbed to its summit.

A British expedition in 1957 stopped short, complying with King Mahendra’s terms that the climbers wouldn’t go to the top of the sacred mountain. Subsequently, Nepal’s government didn’t give any climbing permits for Machapuchare (also spelled Machhapuchchhre or Machhapuchhre). New Zealand climber Bill Denz was rumored to have done it anyway, but no one knows for sure. He died in an avalanche on another mountain, Makalu, in 1983.

—Follow Kenneth Silber on Substack & Bluesky.

Discussion

Register or Login to leave a comment