Splicetoday

Moving Pictures
Nov 17, 2026, 06:27AM

Everybody Knows

The alienation and observation of Atom Egoyan's Exotica.

47198 8 crop huge photo fr 1681311322.jpg.jpg?ixlib=rails 2.1

What makes Atom Egoyan’s films great is not the resolution of their mysteries, but what it leaves open. While his signature is the puzzle box, the pleasure is never from the confirmation that you played the game right. This is why his more neatly-bowed films, like Where the Truth Lies, falter. When the mystery is the only thing holding the film together, solving it—counterintuitively—causes the work to collapse. Sometimes this is used to be intentionally didactic, like with how the purpose of Ararat is ultimately to propagate information about the Armenian genocide. But even there Egoyan imbues his sense of truth with something much more interesting: the stories we tell ourselves regarding the truth. In the case of Ararat, this is rendered through one character’s customs interrogation, which the film cuts back to for its entire runtime. The man is carrying film canisters that can’t be X-rayed, while the customs officer believes he is hiding something else, something less legal. When Egoyan finally reveals their contents, he does it in the dark, allowing for the man to believe that the luggage he was handed by someone else is exactly what he needs to believe it was after all, while the customs officer feels with his own two hands what the truth is.

These are recurring images for Egoyan; not just the airport security checks—which he’s obsessed with—but the narrative one builds in their head being shattered by touch. That physical outreach surpasses the mind’s barriers and breaks whatever delicate chain has been keeping everything together because a touch isn’t something you think about, that you reason into or out of existence, it’s something that physically happens, that your body involuntarily reacts to. It’s why the most transgressive thing that can happen in the club in Exotica is for Bruce Greenwood to reach out and put his hand on Mia Kirshner, ending the delusion that their dynamic in this strip joint is remotely similar to when she used to babysit for him. While once real, the roles they play for each other have become a simulacrum of what they once were, replacing their organic emotions with ones that are atavistic, that let them relive the past before the present started to be something they could no longer confront.

Even though the context of these emotions are concealed for the audience to dig up, they aren’t hidden from the characters themselves. As the Leonard Cohen song that bookends the narrative of Exotica says, “Everybody knows.” It’s a beautifully guffaw-inducing decision by Egoyan to include the song where he does, as Christina’s music of choice to dance to at the club, and it’s also cheeky: “Everybody knows the dice are loaded, everybody knows the game is fixed,” could be an ungenerous description of how Egoyan constructs his movies, carefully manipulating the narrative delivery so that the audience has to follow him along for the ride. But textually, the use of the song also calls attention to the fact that the characters know much more than the audience as the film unfolds. It’s a kind of reverse dramatic irony, where the surreptitious nature of the film is different for the characters and audience: the characters know what they’re doing and why they’re doing it, while the audience is left to piece together the on-screen psychology from afar. In turn, this distance gives Egoyan’s rigged game a certain honesty, where the audience is only allowed to get to know his characters the way that they do any person, not by getting in their head, but observing them.

Discussion

Register or Login to leave a comment