Jimmy, the new Jimmy Stewart biopic, is top-to-bottom hokum. Directed by Aaron Burns, written by Justin Strawhand, and starring KJ Apa as Stewart, Jimmy is structured like a Christian faith-based movie, though it isn’t officially one.
Apa does a passable Stewart impression that doesn’t sound much different from Dana Carvey’s. It also presents a Stewart not far off from his established screen persona. When he gives impassioned speeches over soaring music, they’re delivered in the exact same tone as the ones in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. He talks to his romantic interests in the film much the way he addressed Donna Reed in It’s a Wonderful Life.
The movie begins with Frank Capra (Max Casella) pitching Stewart It’s a Wonderful Life, the movie he made right after returning from the war; the Jimmy film lines up right with that movie’s 80th anniversary. Soon after, there’s a flashback to 1941: fight after winning the Oscar for The Philadelphia Story, Jimmy gets a draft notice. Studio boss Louie B. Mayer (Jason Alexander) makes it clear he can get him out of it, but Stewart insists on serving, after Capra shows him “Why We Fight” footage.
The bulk of the film consists of Stewart’s time serving in Europe, where he flies air missions, is given the duty of writing letters to families of men killed, romances a British lady (Kara Killmer), is repeatedly promoted, and develops what would today be called PTSD.
The dogfight scenes are presented like the ones in Top Gun, but. not as exciting, and there’s little suspense over the war scenes, since we know that Jimmy is going to survive the war, go home to star in It’s a Wonderful Life, Vertigo, and live into his-late 80s. The third act has him return to the States, struggle to readjust, and eventually get his acting career going again, starting with his most famous part. We see him traumatized and not able to recapture his talent, before ultimately implying that his wartime experiences helped Stewart find the necessary darkness to play George Bailey. And much like I Play Rocky, Jimmy borrows its emotional climax, along with multiple lines of dialogue, from the classic movie that it’s about.
Rob Riggle capably plays a military commander, while it’s jarring seeing Max Casella as Capra since the actor, who was Doogie Howser’s best friend and later played a junior mobster on The Sopranos, is now almost 60. The number of moviegoers with a memory of Jimmy Stewart’s acting career is rapidly dwindling, and while It’s a Wonderful Life used to air daily on TV during the holidays, that hasn’t happened years. Jimmy has his heart in the right place, but the film struggles to move beyond its corny limitations.
