This year is the 200th anniversary of the earliest known instance in print of “Hello.” My old hometown of Norwich, CT apparently gets the credit, thanks to an item in the January 18, 1826 issue of the weekly Norwich Courier. But one could easily exaggerate the significance of that artifact by lumping together concepts such as “first use of that spelling,” “first use of that word,” or even “first use of the concept of a greeting-word.” Many inaccurate etymologies—and bad philosophical arguments—happen because people refuse to break a big phenomenon up into its component parts, finding some strategic advantage in pretending the parts have to be lumped together, logically, forever.
People were of course greeting each other before 1826. They were even making a noise more or less like that word, but as far as we know, other spellings such as “hallo” had long been preferred. Nonetheless, perhaps Norwich, sometimes called “the Rose of New England” (two centuries ago about the same size as New York City, though plainly one city has grown more than the other), should try rebranding itself as “Hello City,” even though anyone who has seen 1980s horror movies knows this would be a powerful invitation to area teens to vandalize or erase the “o” in resulting signs. (I miss the 1980s punks of high school.)
Being the birthplace of “hello” beats being known as the birthplace of Benedict Arnold, though he isn’t the only famous person the town has produced. We also produced Samuel Huntington, who signed the Declaration of Independence. (Whether that makes the town sound more prone to spawning traitors or less is open to interpretation.) My old high school English teacher, Wally Lamb, was the first author anointed by Oprah’s Book Club.
Our tendency to accept package deals as permanently unified wholes can make one overlook compound words even more easily than compound concepts. I admit I was alive for decades before it crossed my mind that “tourists” are called that because they “tour,” but our language is filled with less-stupid examples.
Only when libertarian Phil Baltimore recently posted a photo online of the elaborate-looking symbol that meant “percent” back in the Founding Era (a bit like a tiny tic-tac-toe game) did it dawn on me that since “per cent” or “per centum” by definition means per 100, one could render it as “/100,” then over time abbreviate it as “/00,” then loosely (and non-mathematically) stylize it as “0/0,” and soon you and the other participants in your culture have unthinkingly evolved the % symbol. And the original “per cent” name for it remains!
Linguists, by the way, are unsettlingly good at predicting how words will develop contractions or new pronunciations over time. Careful writers and speakers can only sit back and watch with nitpicky horror as certain phrases and words trudge toward doom, too similar to other phrases to retain their independent existence. Try telling the average citizen that the phrase “begs the question” has a highly specific and useful philosophical meaning (basically “unfairly assumes the outcome of the question up for debate”) that is not “pressures us to ask the following” and see how far it gets you these days.
Of greater concern to the philosophy student is the tendency of people to assume that things they’ve always lumped together morally or politically are synonymous or tightly logically bound. If you’re an agnostic like me, try telling religious people, even seemingly very smart ones, that you can care about morality without believing in religion.
On a related note, one benefit of the past decade of political tumult, for all its embarrassing and scary bits, is that it showed people their old Cold War-era checklists of “all the right-wing beliefs” and “all the left-wing beliefs” can be scrambled and rescrambled beyond recognition, perhaps even yielding more logical coalitions than the ones we once knew.
It would help if the most pigheaded right-wingers didn’t attach a specific skin color or geographic location to moral worthiness or treat “America” or “the West” as a rigid package deal exactly to their liking.
And even some fairly moderate-sounding left-liberals would do well to admit the many strange things they’ve been smuggling into their conception of “democracy,” which almost everyone loves when it’s an idea only one word in length but which in recent years seems to have undergone enough definition-creep to turn intelligence agencies, proportional ethnic representation, wealth redistribution, and international military alliances into purported foundational concepts. Yet one can treasure art without treasuring the bureaucracy that is the National Endowment for the Arts, for example.
And similarly, perhaps the unsettling era of omnipresent private surveillance through which we’re living will lead my fellow libertarians to seek ways to unbundle private property and the concept of privacy itself, even for legal purposes.
At the same time, I’m mindful of Edmund Burke’s contrasting warning two-and-a-half centuries ago that some things that look as if they can be easily separated turn out to be organically yoked to each other for reasons we barely grasp. In analyzing, we might be tugging at threads better left entangled. In fact, my own political philosophy can be seen as a form of “fusionism,” combining respect for both morals and markets—but even that specific political label, like all the others, gets used in dangerously varying and misunderstood ways.
The important thing may be, almost always, to avoid insisting that there’s only one way to carve things up.
—Todd Seavey is the author of Libertarianism for Beginners and is on X at @ToddSeavey
