Splicetoday

Writing
Jul 21, 2009, 07:12AM

10 Books You Can Skip

Probably the most insane list I've ever seen.

If you’re looking for reading suggestions in bulk, you’re spoiled for choice. There are classics, like Clifton Fadiman’s Lifetime Reading Plan or Harold Bloom’s The Western Canon. And in recent years, a cottage industry has sprung up of books that recommend books — The Top Ten, Book Lust (and it's follow-up More Book Lust), The Modern Library, etc., etc.Some of these efforts are quite good and owned by the authors of this feature — but a problem arises: Such guides are presumably meant to save readers time by pointing them in the right direction, but the guides themselves amount to several months or years of reading. The books they recommend add up to several lifetimes. What starts as an attempt to save hours ends as a commitment to more hours than you probably have.That’s where we come in. Below is a list of ten books that will be pressed into your hands by ardent fans. Resist these people. Life may not be too short (I’m only in my mid-30s, and already pretty bored), but it’s not endless.

Discussion
  • I haven't read most of the older classics on this list so I won't comment on them. I can certainly do without DeLillo, Franzen, and Garcia-Marquez, so I'm with the writers there. I also kind of get their criticism of Jack Kerouac, who was kind of a one-note author(although no one should go through life without reading On the Road - kind of an important book even if it doesn't meet these jaded critics' standards). But Absalom, Absalom!? The authors of the list quote a passage from the book that almost made me cry, it was so brilliant, and then compare it to swimming through tar. What? The same goes for their essentially misguided criticism of Cormac McCarthy's The Road, which was not McCarthy's best but can still stand proudly against any four or five other recent novels. What is it about book lists that causes people to make obviously controversial decisions for no reason other than to be controversial?

    Responses to this comment

Register or Login to leave a comment