I don’t like the holiday season. It’s too cold and the celebrations feel forced. The holidays were the time when, 36 years ago, my alcoholism ran off the tracks. Blackouts began during Thanksgiving and intensified during advent, culminating in a three-day loss between Christmas and New Year’s. I had my last drink on January 10, 1990.
Still, that was a long time ago. I’m not a preacher, and dislike 12-Step drunkalogues. I prefer to escape the holidays either in Charleston or on the Eastern Shore. These places in winter represent to me a “cold-water Eden.” In his memoir Cold-Water Eden: One Man’s Pursuit of Ireland’s Legendary Waves, Irish surfer Richie Fitzgerald describes being a kid in western Ireland in the 1980s and trying to do what no one else there had tried: surfing. Following the lead of his sister Frankie and with a makeshift wetsuit cobbled together with spare parts and wool cloves, Fitzgerald was a disaster his first time out—except for the few seconds he got up on the board. “There was something about the feeling of sailing on a moving wedge of water that’s other-worldly. I just couldn’t shake it. I found my sister upstairs and said, ‘Hey Frankie, is it OK if I come surfing with you again next weekend?’ to which she replied, ‘I knew you’d enjoy it.’”
Cold-Water Eden is full of scenes of struggle, fear, pushing the limits, raw Irish beauty and triumph. My father took us to Ireland several times in the 1980s so we could see where we came from. I was there as a teenager when Richie was there surfing. The Celtic Seas are wild and dangerous.
I know the thrill Richie describes. In recent years I’ve taken some surfing lessons. As a lifelong skateboarder, I thought I could pick it up easily. Wrong. Surfing is difficult. During my first attempt a few years ago I heard the voice of my high-school football coach when he’d emerge from the gym onto the practice football field at seven a.m. during the brutal August football camp: “IT’S A GOOD DAY TO DIE GENTLEMEN!”
Surfing is an effective way to treat trauma. Trauma shocks the human soul and brain into being what Kurt Vonnegut called “stuck in time.” My trauma was mostly similar to everyone else’s—the death of parents and family members, abusive and broken relationships, near-death experiences. I’d also been politically mauled in 2018 when my high-school friend Brett Kavanaugh was nominated to the Supreme Court and was falsely accused of sexual assault when we were in high school while I looked on.
As Vonnegut puts it early in the documentary Unstuck in Time, a lot of his stories have the same theme: people getting ejected from an idyllic Eden and cast into a violent, commercialized, and insane world. In books like The Sirens of Titan (1959) or Breakfast of Champions (1973), there’s irony and a stoic acceptance of tragedy. Vonnegut’s most famous reoccurring line is “and so it goes.” This isn’t nihilism or resignation as much as wisdom gained about the tragic aspect of life, the view of someone who saw the carpet bombing of an entire city in World War II.
Yet there comes a time not for sorrow, but joy, and abundance. The book I took to the beach with me isn’t Vonnegut but A Boob's Life: How America's Obsession Shaped Me―and You by Leslie Lehr. Boobs are great healers. Over the years I’d been lucky enough to date a couple of big-breasted women, one of whom could make Russ Meyer take notice.
Lehr is a polished journalist so the book delves into both personal history and sociology. “The truth is,” she writes, “my breasts have been loathed and loved, suckled and stuffed, radiated and reconstructed. They have doomed one marriage and inspired another. Yet, every step of the way, they’ve had the finest treatment in America. By now, they should be perfect.” Lehr also traces the hoister of what she calls our “breast obsession.” It really kicked in after World War II:
The concept of abundance overruled reality. Men designed “training bras” for girls, push-up bras for teens, plus inflatable bras and artificial augmentation for women. Playboy ushered in the sexual revolution with “girls next door.” And then, during the postwar baby boom, doctors endorsed newfangled infant formula. That made it official: breasts were no longer for babies. Thanks to a perfect storm of the baby boom, modern medicine, television, Madison Avenue, and Playboy, America became obsessed with breasts.
I think the love of breasts is more primal and less political than that. Breasts are life-giving providers of life and joy. They come from heaven. One of my busty friends once sent me a picture of herself topless with a note: “You’ve had enough trauma. Have some joy.” Boobs should be treated with reverence and awe, as works of art, not with mocking or cheap pornography.
I was reading A Boob’s Life and watching the rough, November Atlantic Ocean when I noticed that Lear’s book had taken a sharp turn towards the political. Somehow a book about tits had pivoted into a rant about Brett Kavanaugh:
In September, we watched Brett Kavanaugh get confirmed for the Supreme Court without regard for Christine Blasey Ford’s sobering account of sexual assault. The bro culture and tribe mentality of the Senate Judiciary Committee was so steeped in entitlement that nothing a Stanford professor could say would stop it. Like my father, these conservative white men bulldozed their way forward, never pausing to see the destruction they sowed. As long as they appreciated how women looked, and the ones they supported, supported them in return, they believed they were pro-women. The stereotype of emotionally weak females was reversed when steely-eyed Ford laid out her case against this hysterical man. As I watched Kavanaugh have a tantrum that any toddler’s mother would put a stop to, another picture came to mind: a pubic hair on a Coke can. The parallels of Anita Hill’s testimony during Justice Clarence Thomas’s confirmation hearings were unavoidable. I was pregnant with Chloe in 1991, trying not to vomit while I watched the calm female lawyer be dismissed after describing her boss’s abuse. I had been so sure that life would be different for my daughters. But there was no way to stop the good ole boys from winning.
Like so many other things, boobs couldn’t even be discussed without a liberal making it about Trump. A book about boobs written by one.
The ocean was loud and rough. I’d probably be the only one out there.
