Splicetoday

Pop Culture
Nov 17, 2026, 06:28AM

Frankenstein Has a Handover Problem

His creature isn’t a machine awaiting an operator.

Download  13 .jpeg?ixlib=rails 2.1

Victor Frankenstein gets the result he wants, and then leaves the room.

In Mary Shelley’s 1818 novel, he spends nearly two years trying to give life to an inanimate body. When the creature breathes, Victor’s triumph turns to disgust. He retreats to his bedroom, and then flees again when the creature approaches his bed. The experiment has succeeded by the measure that consumed him. He can’t bear to be there for what happens next.

I’ve spent more than 25 years in precision manufacturing. That makes the unfinished business around a finished job hard to miss. Someone has to understand what was done, what remains uncertain, and what the next person will inherit. The excitement of making something work can end long before the work stops mattering.

Calling Victor’s failure a handover problem sounds offensively small. His creature isn’t a machine awaiting an operator. He’s a being capable of pain, affection, judgment and terrible choices. That’s where the comparison becomes useful: Victor’s achievement creates obligations far beyond the satisfaction of getting a result. There’s no receiving department to which he can transfer them.

Before the creature lives, Victor imagines a new species blessing him. He pictures gratitude flowing toward its creator. He’s already cast himself as an extraordinary father, with extraordinary claims on his children, without doing the ordinary work of being present for one.

The creature’s appearance breaks that fantasy. Victor has selected features he considers beautiful, yet the living whole horrifies him. His rejection’s immediate. The new being has scarcely begun to move before his maker decides he can’t endure the sight.

This leaves a disturbing gap between Victor’s account of his effort and his account of its consequences. The labor earns pages of explanation. Staying with the life he’s made is apparently unbearable. He wants the reader to understand how much the experiment cost him. The creature has to explain for himself what Victor’s departure cost somebody else.

Even that account reaches us through Victor’s telling and Walton’s letters. Nobody has an unfiltered account of the whole story. Victor keeps naming what he sees before the creature describes what he feels. A grotesque face becomes a moral explanation; the reader is asked to accept the label before hearing the history. Shelley makes us sit through the history anyway. The change in speaker interrupts the comfortable possibility that the man with the laboratory knows his creation best. He knows how he made the body. The creature knows what living in it has been like.

That history takes shape around the De Lacy family. The creature learns language by listening and watches their kindness to one another. When he understands that stealing their food worsens their poverty, he stops. He gathers wood to ease their work. These are small, practical acts of attention. They make a strong answer to the idea that his body contains a finished moral verdict.

They also expose something humiliating about Victor. The abandoned creature can notice another household’s needs and change his behavior. The educated man who made him can’t get past his own revulsion long enough to provide comparable care.

The creature’s account is an argument, however, not an acquittal. “I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend,” he tells Victor. That sentence is a claim about how he became cruel, delivered by someone seeking a response from the man he holds responsible. We should hear the suffering without handing over our judgment.

He murders Victor’s young brother William and plants the miniature William was wearing on the sleeping Justine, directing suspicion toward her. Injury becomes a justification for injuring people who didn’t create him. His intelligence makes the choice more appalling. The same being who can understand the cottagers’ hunger can understand that these victims will suffer.

Responsibility has spread, not changed hands. Victor’s abandonment remains his failure; the creature’s revenge becomes his own. Neither man’s guilt clears the other. Shelley makes that uncomfortable arrangement harder to escape than a story in which the experiment simply releases something evil.

The proposed companion brings the difficulty into sharper focus. Victor eventually agrees to create a female being. Later, he recognizes that she might reject the agreement under which the two creatures are supposed to withdraw from human society. She’s made no promise. She might refuse her intended companion altogether.

That’s a serious objection. Another conscious life can’t fairly be treated as compensation delivered to an unhappy customer. The creature assumes that a woman made like him will want him; Victor has agreed to produce her before facing the possibility that she might want something else. Both imagine her future around their own relief.

Victor also fears the consequences of their having children. He destroys the unfinished companion. His concern for others has become real, but it arrives inside another secret undertaking, another promise, another irreversible act. The novel gives no reason to believe that merely completing the second body would’ve repaired the wrong done to the first.

This is why a neat lesson about better planning can’t contain the book. Victor can’t write a sufficiently thorough instruction sheet to settle another person’s life. He has to answer somebody who can refuse him, accuse him, and demand things he may have good reasons not to provide. Responsibility requires judgment after the achievement. It can’t be completed in advance.

The novel’s Arctic frame offers a less spectacular decision. The explorer Robert Walton wants discovery and distinction. His crew, trapped in ice, wants an assurance that he’ll turn south if escape becomes possible. Victor responds with an appeal to courage and glory, urging the sailors to continue. Even after telling his story, he can still make another man’s dangerous ambition sound noble.

Walton eventually agrees to return. He resents the decision and describes his hopes as ruined. The book doesn’t reward him with the clean satisfaction of becoming wise. He has to bear disappointment while the people whose lives depend on him get their chance to go home.

There’s something solid in that imperfect surrender. Walton listens to a demand that interrupts the story he wants to tell about himself. He lets the people doing the work have a claim on its direction. They have lives beyond his expedition.

Victor finds it easier to endure extraordinary labor than an ordinary obligation that won’t flatter him. The creature’s first breath doesn’t finish his work. It takes away his excuse for working alone. What follows needs the man who stayed up making life to stay in the room with him.

Discussion

Register or Login to leave a comment