The Decentralized Utopia

Can we focus on a different goal?

Rsz 84b9729c2ddb01062ab44f920b2cf41b.jpg?ixlib=rails 1.1

The standard dream of Web utopianism involves Rhizomatic anarchic democratization; open source ground-up power to the people. At its most starry-eyed, this dream becomes a teleological claim that the Internet itself can topple dictators and uproot authoritarianism. More soberly, it’s expressed as a hope rather than as a necessity. Corey Doctorow writes in a recent post as Boing Boing:

"For me, the interesting question isn't ‘does technology centralize or doesn't it?’ We've seen technology do both. For me, the interesting question is, ‘How can we make technology into a force for decentralization?’"

I agree with Doctorow that technology can have a wide range of effects. Social media makes it possible for any number of people to engage in news gathering or reporting; on the other hand, having so much news gathering online makes it relatively easy for centralized authorities to shut it down through control of servers or networks. But while it’s true that the Internet can result in centralization or decentralization, I disagree that the goal should always be to figure out a way to move towards decentralization.

Decentralization isn’t always a good thing. This is particularly true in an American context. The most important historical move towards decentralization in the U.S. was Southern secession; the second most important was probably the demand for States' rights exceptionalism that formed the philosophical underpinning for Jim Crow. Anti-centralization in the U.S. has traditionally, and insistently, been linked to racism—=which is why it's not especially surprising that libertarian heroes like Ron Paul and Rand Paul have found themselves tied to various racist enterprises and cronies.

Even beyond the queasy link between decentralization and neo-Confederate thought, there are plenty of situations in which greater centralization might be beneficial. Single-payer isn't necessarily a solution for all our health care woes, but it would insure more people and be a simpler and more cost-effective health care system than the one we had pre-Obamacare, or than the one we have now. Less controversially, I doubt even the most hardcore tech utopian or anarchist would suggest that control of nuclear weapons should be decentralized; a President with the ability to destroy the world is nerve-wracking, but 50 state governors with the power to do so would be 50 times so. Even the goal of democratization itself requires a certain amount of centralization; Occupy Wall Street's deflation was probably linked to its ideological refusal to create a leadership structure.

Now, centralization isn't necessarily good either. Economic monopolies, whether Standard Oil or Google, often hurt consumers, and a federal government which allows itself the right to assassinate its own citizens without due process is a scary thing. Like Doctorow, I worry about the way that technology enables ever-increasing surveillance, and suspect that such surveillance will inevitably turn to political ends. But I also think that decentralization can lead to a kind of quasi-legal, crowd-sourced enabling of abuse—as with revenge porn, in which for profit sites post nude photo without the subject's consent.

The point is that centralization/decentralization is not an ethical heuristic. Whether or not we have a racist society; whether or not everyone has equal access to health care; whether or not we execute people without due process—those are important moral issues that should guide policy. But there's nothing innately moral or immoral about a more or less centralized administrative system, just as there's nothing innately moral or immoral about technology itself. Rather than asking how we can use technology to encourage decentralization, it would be better to ask how we can use technology to promote freedom and equality. Whether that's done through centralization or decentralization doesn't seem like it should matter that much.

—Follow Noah Berlatsky on Twitter: @hoodedu

Add a comment
Register to leave a comment